The Tree
A daughter and her father argue over the old cedar her grandfather planted at the family’s events venue, until someone settles it for them.
Email - Priya Shah to Raj Shah, 18 April
Dad,
We need to make a decision about the cedar.
Another branch came down last night. It missed the terrace, but not by much.
We’ve now had two warnings from the arborist and one from the insurer.
I know Grandad planted it. I know what it means to you.
But we can’t keep treating that as a reason to ignore the risk.
Email - Raj Shah to Priya Shah, 18 April
Priya,
I’m not ignoring anything.
Have it crowned again.
Put supports in if that’s what they recommend.
Close that side of the terrace when the weather’s bad.
We are not cutting it down.
Your grandfather planted that tree the year we opened.
Email - Priya Shah to Raj Shah, 2 May
Dad,
We’ve spent nearly £4,000 on it in three years.
The arborist has now put in writing that another large branch could come down.
If somebody gets hurt at a wedding, saying Grandad planted it isn’t going to make any difference.
I’m not trying to get rid of him.
It’s a tree.
I’m trying to stop somebody getting hurt.
Contractor work order - Hawthorn Tree Services, 17 May
Client: Shah House Events
Site: Shah House, West Terrace
Work requested: Remove mature cedar tree.
Authorised by: Priya Shah
Client note:
Raj has agreed.
Please get it done before Saturday if possible.
Take stump down as far as you can.
Text messages - Priya and Dad, 17 May
Email - Hawthorn Tree Services to Priya Shah, 17 May
Hi Priya,
I’ve checked this after your call.
The removal request came through your normal account on Tuesday afternoon.
The note on the job said:
“Raj has agreed. Please get it done before he changes his mind.”
We took that to mean you’d both agreed to the work.
By the time your dad came outside and asked us to stop, the main stem had already been cut and we couldn’t safely leave the tree standing.
I’m sorry. I appreciate this is obviously not what you were expecting.
IT support note - Shah House Events, 18 May
Priya Shah reports possible unauthorised account use.
User states tree-removal booking was made without her knowledge.
Account activity reviewed.
Login originated from recognised office network.
MFA successfully completed.
No external login identified.
Password reset completed.
User advised no evidence of compromise found.
Ticket closed.
Voice message - Raj Shah to Priya Shah, 20 May
Unsent note - Priya Shah, 21 May
I did want it down.
That’s why this works.
Dad knows I did.
There are emails from me saying it was dangerous. There are loads of them.
But I didn’t book those people.
I didn’t tell them he’d agreed.
Somebody knew exactly what to put in that message.
I’ve copied the access logs.
Sent them to my own email as well.
Probably shouldn’t have done that but I don’t know what else I’m meant to do.
Disciplinary outcome - Shah House Events, 28 May
Following an internal review, Ms Priya Shah’s employment has been terminated.
Matters considered included:
- unauthorised download of restricted access records
- forwarding company information to a personal email address
- repeated allegations of deliberate interference without supporting evidence
The tree-removal instruction remains recorded against Ms Shah’s authenticated account.
Ms Shah disputes having submitted it.
Succession arrangements are suspended.
Operation Lintel - Shah House Events
Read next
- LENA-4A family’s new android caregiver becomes indispensable to their daughter in ways no one agreed to.Like Us · Dystopia · 15 documents · about 6 min
- Settling InRachel's new home companion arrives with a 90-day settling-in period, and a few things she must not change.Like Us · Dystopia · 8 documents · about 8 min
- A Good CallDaniel’s father says their Sunday calls mean everything to him. Daniel hasn’t made one in six weeks.Like Us · Dystopia · 8 documents · about 8 min